When it comes to shoes, sizing can often be a tricky topic. Many of us have been led to believe certain things about shoe size that simply aren’t true. Whether it’s myths passed down by well-meaning family members or tips we’ve heard from friends, these misconceptions can lead us to make poor choices when it comes to finding the right pair of shoes. Unfortunately, shoe sizing issues don’t only cause discomfort—they can also lead to long-term foot problems.
We’ll be debunking 10 common shoe size myths. By the end of this article, you’ll be equipped with the facts you need to make smarter decisions when it comes to buying shoes, ensuring both comfort and better foot health.
1. Myth: Shoe Size Remains the Same Throughout Your Life
Debunked: Your shoe size can change over time, and this is completely natural. As we age, the ligaments and tendons in our feet lose some of their elasticity, which can cause the feet to widen or lengthen. Pregnancy, weight gain, and even certain health conditions like arthritis can also impact the shape and size of your feet. This means that just because you wore a certain size in your 20s doesn’t mean that same size will work for you in your 40s.
The Fact: It’s important to measure your feet regularly and reassess your shoe size, especially when you notice discomfort or if you’re going through a significant life change.
2. Myth: Your Shoe Size Is the Same Across All Brands
Debunked: Shoe sizing is not universal, and different brands often use different sizing systems. A size 8 from one brand may fit completely differently than a size 8 from another. Manufacturers don’t always follow the same measurements or guidelines, and the fit of a shoe can vary significantly based on its style (e.g., athletic shoes vs. high heels).
The Fact: Always check the brand’s specific size chart before buying shoes, and when possible, try on the shoes or read reviews from other customers about fit. Even if you know your size in one brand, it’s worth double-checking with each new purchase.
3. Myth: You Should Always Buy Shoes That Are the Exact Fit
Debunked: Shoes that are too tight or too loose are never ideal, but the assumption that your shoes should fit perfectly from the moment you try them on isn’t always accurate. Some shoes, particularly leather or canvas ones, will stretch over time and conform to the shape of your foot. However, there’s a fine line—buying shoes that are too tight at first can lead to blisters, while shoes that are too loose can cause discomfort and foot problems later.
The Fact: A good fit should feel snug but not restrictive. If shoes feel too tight at first, consider how the material may stretch. If they feel too loose, there’s a risk of slipping or rubbing, so it’s essential to find a balance.
4. Myth: All You Need Is the Length of Your Foot to Determine Your Shoe Size
Debunked: Length is just one aspect of shoe sizing. Foot width is just as important. Many people have feet that are wider or narrower than the average shoe accommodates, which can lead to discomfort, especially in shoes that don’t have width options. Shoes that are too narrow can squeeze your toes, while shoes that are too wide may lack the necessary support.
The Fact: When buying shoes, always consider both length and width. Many brands offer shoes in multiple width sizes, so it’s essential to measure both. If your feet are wider or narrower than the standard width, opt for shoes with the appropriate width for your foot.
5. Myth: You Should Always Size Up If Your Shoes Are Slightly Tight
Debunked: While it might seem logical to size up if shoes are a little tight, this isn’t always the best solution. Shoes that are too big can cause your feet to slide around, leading to blisters and discomfort. Sizing up also doesn’t solve the problem if the shoe is too narrow in the toe box or too high in the arch.
The Fact: If shoes feel tight in certain areas, it’s important to figure out if it’s the length, width, or shape of the shoe that’s the problem. Sometimes, it’s better to look for a different style or brand that will fit your foot’s unique shape more comfortably.
Read More: How to Match Your Shoe Size with Foot Shape: A Comprehensive Guide
6. Myth: You Shouldn’t Buy Shoes Online Without Trying Them On First
Debunked: While trying on shoes in person has its advantages, buying shoes online can be just as successful, provided you take a few extra steps. With the convenience of online shopping, many people successfully buy shoes online without ever trying them on first. The key to buying shoes online is knowing your foot measurements, understanding the brand’s sizing chart, and reading customer reviews regarding fit.
The Fact: Buying shoes online can work just as well as shopping in-store if you follow the right steps. Always measure your feet, consult the brand’s size chart, and check return policies in case you need to exchange or return the shoes.
7. Myth: You Can’t Wear High Heels if You Have Wide Feet
Debunked: High heels can be uncomfortable for wide feet, but this doesn’t mean wide-footed individuals should automatically avoid them. Many brands offer wide-width options for heels, and with the right fit, high heels can be worn comfortably by people with wider feet.
The Fact: If you have wide feet and love wearing heels, look for brands that specialize in wide-width shoes or opt for styles with wider toe boxes. Consider also choosing heels with lower, chunkier heels for better stability and comfort.
8. Myth: If Your Shoes Are Too Loose, You Can Just Add Insoles to Fix the Fit
Debunked: Insoles can help with certain comfort or support issues, but they are not a magical solution for poor-fitting shoes. If shoes are too loose, insoles may only provide a temporary fix, and they won’t necessarily correct problems like slipping or blisters. In some cases, using insoles in shoes that are too big may exacerbate the problem and cause your feet to slide even more.
The Fact: If shoes are too loose, it’s best to either go a size down or find a pair that better fits your foot shape. Insoles can offer additional comfort, but they shouldn’t be relied upon as the sole solution for a poor fit.
9. Myth: You Can Tell Your Shoe Size Based on Your Foot Length Alone
Debunked: Foot length is just one of the factors that determine your shoe size. While it is important to know the length of your foot, it’s equally essential to measure your foot’s width, arch height, and overall shape. These factors can influence how the shoe fits and feels once you put it on.
The Fact: The best way to determine your shoe size is to measure both the length and width of your foot, taking into account any specific foot shape considerations. This will give you a more accurate idea of which size and width are best for you.
10. Myth: Shoes Should Only Be Tight in the Toe Area for a Proper Fit
Debunked: While the toe area of the shoe should be snug, a proper fit also requires ample space in other areas. For example, shoes that are too tight in the arch or heel can cause pain and discomfort, even if the toes feel okay. Tightness in the arch can restrict blood flow, while tightness in the heel can lead to blisters and friction.
The Fact: A good-fitting shoe should feel comfortable all over. There should be enough room in the toe box for your toes to move freely, but the heel and arch should also feel secure. Shoes should fit snugly without causing discomfort or pressure anywhere on your foot.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. How often should I measure my feet?
It’s a good idea to measure your feet at least once a year or whenever you notice changes in foot comfort, such as pain or swelling. You may need to measure your feet more often if you’re going through significant changes, like pregnancy or weight gain.
2. Can I trust shoe size charts online?
Shoe size charts can be helpful, but always remember that sizing varies by brand. Always measure your feet and check the brand’s specific size chart to ensure the best fit.
3. What should I do if my shoes are too tight?
If shoes feel too tight, it’s best to try a larger size or a different width if available. If you’re in between sizes, consult customer reviews for more insight on whether the shoe runs small or large.
4. Can I wear high heels if I have wide feet?
Yes! Many brands offer wide-width heels. Look for styles that have a wider toe box or a lower, chunkier heel for better stability and comfort.
5. How do I know if a shoe is the right width for my feet?
The shoe should feel snug around the middle of your foot without pinching. If the shoe feels tight across the ball of your foot or your toes are cramped, you may need a wider size.
6. Is it better to buy shoes that are slightly big or slightly small?
It’s generally better to go slightly larger, especially if your shoes feel tight or restrictive. However, shoes that are too big can cause other issues, so it’s important to find the right balance.
7. How can I make sure my online shoe purchase fits properly?
Measure both the length and width of your feet, consult the size chart, read customer reviews, and check the store’s return policy to ensure you can return or exchange shoes if they don’t fit.
Conclusion
Understanding shoe size myths and knowing how to properly measure your feet can make all the difference when choosing shoes. By debunking these common misconceptions, you can make more informed decisions, ensuring that your shoes fit well, are comfortable, and provide the necessary support. Remember, shoe sizing isn’t always straightforward, but with the right knowledge, you can find shoes that suit your feet perfectly.
Suggest Tools
