The Best Pack and Play Mattress – A Comprehensive Guide for Parents
As a parent, ensuring your baby has a safe, comfortable, and portable sleep environment is a top priority, especially when traveling or visiting family. A Pack and Play, also known as a playard, is a versatile solution that serves as a crib, playpen, and sometimes even a changing station. However, the standard mattresses that come with most Pack and Plays are often thin, firm, and not always ideal for extended sleep. This is where a high-quality Pack and Play mattress comes in, offering enhanced comfort while maintaining safety standards.
We’ll explore the best Pack and Play mattresses available in 2025, based on safety, comfort, portability, and parent reviews. We’ll also cover key factors to consider when choosing a mattress, safety guidelines, and answer 11 frequently asked questions to help you make an informed decision. Whether you’re a first-time parent or looking to upgrade your baby’s travel sleep setup, this post has you covered.
Why You Might Need a Pack and Play Mattress
Pack and Plays are designed for convenience, folding into a compact bag for easy travel. They provide a safe space for your baby to sleep or play, whether at home, at a grandparent’s house, or on vacation. However, the included mattresses are typically thin (often less than an inch thick) and made of firm materials to meet safety standards. While these mattresses are functional, many parents find them too hard for their baby’s comfort, especially for frequent or overnight use.
A dedicated Pack and Play mattress can:
- Enhance Comfort: Add a layer of cushioning for better sleep without compromising safety.
- Improve Portability: Many aftermarket mattresses fold up compactly and include carrying bags.
- Ensure Safety: High-quality options meet strict safety standards to reduce risks like suffocation or entrapment.
- Simplify Cleaning: Waterproof and washable covers make dealing with messes a breeze.
However, adding a mattress isn’t without controversy. Some pediatricians and safe sleep advocates caution against aftermarket mattresses due to potential safety risks, such as gaps or overly soft surfaces. This guide will help you navigate these concerns to find a mattress that balances comfort and safety.
Key Factors to Consider When Choosing a Pack and Play Mattress
Before diving into our top picks, let’s review the essential factors to keep in mind when selecting a Pack and Play mattress:
- Size and Fit:
- The mattress must fit snugly inside your Pack and Play with no gaps between the mattress and the playard walls. Gaps can pose an entrapment or suffocation hazard.
- Standard Pack and Play dimensions are approximately 38” x 26”, but always measure your playard to confirm.
- Safety Certifications:
- Look for mattresses with certifications like Greenguard Gold, CertiPUR-US, or JPMA (Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association). These ensure the product is free of harmful chemicals and meets safety standards.
- The mattress should be firm to reduce the risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS), especially for infants under 12 months.
- Thickness:
- Most safety guidelines recommend Pack and Play mattresses be no thicker than 1.5 inches to maintain the playard’s structural integrity and prevent climbing hazards.
- Thicker mattresses (e.g., 3 inches) may be suitable for toddlers over 12 months but are generally not recommended for younger infants.
- Material and Breathability:
- Breathable materials, like organic cotton or ventilated memory foam, help regulate temperature and reduce the risk of overheating.
- Avoid non-breathable materials that could increase suffocation risks if a baby rolls face-down.
- Portability:
- A tri-fold design or a carrying bag makes the mattress easy to transport, especially for frequent travelers.
- Lightweight options (under 6 pounds) are ideal for on-the-go families.
- Washability:
- Babies are messy, so choose a mattress with a removable, machine-washable, and waterproof cover for easy cleaning.
- Some mattresses have dual-sided covers (firm for infants, softer for toddlers) to grow with your child.
- Durability:
- A well-made mattress should withstand repeated folding, travel, and use without losing shape or support.
- Look for reinforced edges to prevent buckling when your baby stands or leans against the sides.
- Price:
- Pack and Play mattresses range from $30 to $100+. Higher-priced options often include premium materials or added features like organic cotton or dual-sided designs.
- Balance cost with quality, as a safe and durable mattress is a worthwhile investment.
The Best Pack and Play Mattresses of 2025
After researching parent reviews, safety standards, and product features, here are our top picks for the best Pack and Play mattresses in 2025. Each option has been evaluated for safety, comfort, portability, and ease of use.
1. Hiccapop Pack and Play Mattress Pad
- Best Overall
- Dimensions: 38” x 26” x 1.5”
- Weight: 5.96 pounds
- Key Features:
- Dual-sided: Firm side for infants, softer memory foam side for toddlers.
- Waterproof, machine-washable TPU cover with a zipper for easy removal.
- Tri-fold design with a carrying bag for portability.
- Anti-skid gripping dots on the bottom to prevent sliding.
- Greenguard Gold and CertiPUR-US certified for safety.
- Why We Love It:
The Hiccapop mattress is a favorite among parents for its versatility and safety features. With nearly 33,000 Amazon reviews, it’s praised for its snug fit, lightweight design, and easy-to-clean cover. The dual-sided design makes it suitable for babies from newborn to toddler age, and the anti-skid dots ensure stability during active play. One reviewer noted, “This mattress pad fits perfectly in our Graco Pack and Play, adding just enough cushion for my baby to sleep comfortably.” - Considerations:
Some parents find the toddler side too soft for infants, so stick to the firm side for babies under 12 months. The cover isn’t waterproof unless paired with a separate protector.
2. Dream On Me On-The-Go Tri-Fold Playard Mattress
- Best for Portability
- Dimensions: 38” x 26” x 1.5”
- Weight: 4.5 pounds
- Key Features:
- Tri-fold design with a carrying bag for easy travel.
- Waterproof, vinyl cover for quick cleaning.
- Greenguard Gold and JPMA certified.
- Durable construction with a 10-year warranty.
- Why We Love It:
This mattress strikes a balance between affordability, portability, and safety. Its lightweight design and compact fold make it ideal for frequent travelers, and the waterproof cover simplifies cleanup after spills or accidents. Parents appreciate the firm yet comfortable surface, with one Walmart reviewer stating, “My baby loves it, and it folds down to a third of its size for easy transport.” - Considerations:
The vinyl cover can feel less soft than fabric options, so a fitted sheet is recommended for added comfort. It lacks a dual-sided design, so it’s less versatile for older toddlers.
3. Organic Dream Graco Pack and Play Mattress
- Best Organic Option
- Dimensions: 38” x 26” x 1.5”
- Weight: 6 pounds
- Key Features:
- Made with 100% organic cotton and CertiPUR-US foam.
- Breathable, hypoallergenic cover promotes airflow.
- Reinforced perimeter support to prevent edge buckling.
- Dual-sided: Firm for infants, responsive support for toddlers.
- Greenguard Gold certified for low emissions.
- Why We Love It:
For eco-conscious parents, the Organic Dream mattress offers a chemical-free sleep surface with premium materials. Its breathable design keeps babies cool, and the reinforced edges provide extra safety as babies start to stand. One parent shared, “The organic cotton feels so soft, and I love knowing my baby is sleeping on a non-toxic mattress.” - Considerations:
It’s pricier than other options, and the cover isn’t machine-washable (spot-clean only). It’s also slightly heavier, which may be a drawback for frequent travel.
4. Milliard Tri-Fold Pack and Play Mattress
- Best Budget Option
- Dimensions: 38” x 26” x 1.5”
- Weight: 5 pounds
- Key Features:
- Tri-fold design with a free carrying case.
- Waterproof, removable cover for easy cleaning.
- Breathable foam construction for temperature regulation.
- CertiPUR-US certified.
- Why We Love It:
The Milliard mattress offers excellent value without skimping on safety or comfort. Its lightweight, foldable design is perfect for travel, and the waterproof cover makes it parent-friendly. A What to Expect community member raved, “I got a Milliard mattress! So cozy and no sheet bunching.” - Considerations:
It’s slightly less durable than premium options, and the cover may wear out with frequent washing. Some parents note it’s firmer than expected, which is ideal for infants but less so for toddlers.
5. Sleepah Pack and Play Mattress
- Best for Durability
- Dimensions: 38” x 26” x 1.5”
- Weight: 5.5 pounds
- Key Features:
- High-density foam for long-lasting support.
- Waterproof, washable cover with organic cotton fabric.
- Tri-fold design with a carrying bag.
- CertiPUR-US and Oeko-Tex Standard 100 certified.
- Why We Love It:
The Sleepah mattress is built to withstand years of use, making it a great choice for families with multiple children. Its high-density foam maintains shape even with active toddlers, and the organic cotton cover adds a touch of luxury. Parents appreciate its snug fit and easy maintenance. - Considerations:
It’s slightly heavier than other tri-fold options, which may affect portability. The price is mid-range, but it’s worth it for the durability.
Safety Guidelines for Using a Pack and Play Mattress
Safety is paramount when choosing and using a Pack and Play mattress. Follow these guidelines to ensure your baby’s sleep environment is secure:
- Use Only Approved Mattresses:
- Avoid standard crib mattresses or toppers, as they’re too thick and can create gaps or instability.
- Choose mattresses specifically designed for Pack and Plays, with dimensions that match your playard.
- Check for a Snug Fit:
- There should be no gaps between the mattress and the playard walls. A gap larger than two fingers is a safety hazard.
- Secure the mattress with Velcro straps (if provided) to prevent shifting.
- Follow Safe Sleep Practices:
- Place babies on their back to sleep to reduce SIDS risk.
- Avoid adding blankets, pillows, or stuffed animals to the playard.
- Use a fitted sheet designed for Pack and Play mattresses to prevent bunching.
- Adhere to Age and Weight Limits:
- Most Pack and Plays have a weight limit of 30 pounds or a height limit of 35 inches. Check your playard’s manual.
- Discontinue use if your child attempts to climb out, regardless of age or weight.
- Monitor Mattress Thickness:
- For infants under 12 months, stick to mattresses 1.5 inches or thinner to maintain a firm sleep surface.
- Thicker mattresses may be suitable for toddlers over 12 months, but consult your playard’s manufacturer guidelines.
- Ensure Proper Ventilation:
- Choose a mattress with breathable materials to reduce the risk of overheating or suffocation.
- Regularly inspect the playard’s mesh walls for tears or damage.
- Check for Recalls:
- Before purchasing, verify that the mattress and playard haven’t been recalled. Check the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) website for updates.
Pros and Cons of Adding a Pack and Play Mattress
Pros:
- Improved Comfort: A mattress can make the playard more inviting for naps and overnight sleep, especially for babies who dislike hard surfaces.
- Portability: Many mattresses fold compactly and include carrying bags, making them easy to travel with.
- Easy Maintenance: Waterproof and washable covers simplify cleanup after messes.
- Versatility: Dual-sided mattresses can grow with your child from infancy to toddlerhood.
- Safety Features: Certified mattresses meet strict standards for firmness and low emissions.
Cons:
- Safety Concerns: Improperly fitted or overly soft mattresses can increase the risk of suffocation or entrapment.
- Cost: Quality mattresses range from $30 to $100, adding to the overall cost of your playard setup.
- Weight: Some mattresses add bulk, which may be inconvenient for frequent travelers.
- Compatibility Issues: Not all mattresses fit every Pack and Play model, requiring careful measurement.
- Debate Over Necessity: Some parents argue the standard mattress is sufficient, as babies don’t need soft surfaces like adults do.
How to Make Your Pack and Play Mattress More Comfortable (Safely)
If you’re hesitant to add a mattress or want to enhance the standard one, here are safe ways to improve comfort:
- Use a Fitted Sheet:
- A quilted or stretchy Pack and Play sheet can add a slight layer of softness without compromising safety. Brands like COSMOPLUS offer soft, stretchy sheets that prevent bunching.
- Ensure the sheet is made by the playard manufacturer or specifically designed for Pack and Play mattresses.
- Add a Waterproof Mattress Protector:
- A thin, waterproof protector (like the American Baby Company Quilted Mattress Pad) can provide a bit of cushioning while keeping the mattress clean.
- Check that the protector fits snugly and doesn’t create gaps.
- Adjust the Playard Setup:
- Ensure the playard is on a flat, stable surface to maximize mattress support.
- For Graco models, secure the mattress with Velcro straps to prevent shifting, especially if your baby is active.
- Consider a Bassinet Insert:
- For newborns, a bassinet insert raises the sleep surface, making it easier to reach your baby and potentially more comfortable.
Note: Never add blankets, towels, or plush toppers to soften the mattress, as these increase suffocation risks.
Comparing Pack and Play Mattresses: A Quick Reference Table
| Mattress | Price | Dimensions | Weight | Key Features | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hiccapop | ~$55 | 38” x 26” x 1.5” | 5.96 lbs | Dual-sided, waterproof, tri-fold, anti-skid | Overall |
| Dream On Me | ~$45 | 38” x 26” x 1.5” | 4.5 lbs | Tri-fold, waterproof, 10-year warranty | Portability |
| Organic Dream | ~$90 | 38” x 26” x 1.5” | 6 lbs | Organic cotton, breathable, dual-sided | Eco-conscious |
| Milliard | ~$40 | 38” x 26” x 1.5” | 5 lbs | Tri-fold, waterproof, affordable | Budget |
| Sleepah | ~$60 | 38” x 26” x 1.5” | 5.5 lbs | High-density foam, organic cotton, durable | Durability |
Real Parent Experiences with Pack and Play Mattresses
To provide a well-rounded perspective, we’ve gathered insights from parents on forums like Reddit, What to Expect, and The Bump:
- Positive Feedback:
- A Reddit user shared, “We got a lightly quilted sheet for our Pack and Play, and it made a huge difference. Our baby sleeps just as well as in his crib now.”
- On What to Expect, a parent said, “The Milliard mattress is cozy and fits perfectly in our Graco. No bunching with the sheets, and my toddler loves it.”
- Another parent noted, “The Hiccapop mattress was a game-changer for travel. It folds easily, and my baby sleeps longer on it than the standard mat.”
- Concerns and Cautions:
- A Reddit poster expressed frustration: “I wanted a mattress because the Pack and Play mat is so hard, but everyone warned me about SIDS risks. I ended up using the standard one with a fitted sheet.”
- On The Bump, a user advised, “Don’t add anything that doesn’t come with the Pack and Play. The manual says it’s a suffocation risk, and I’d rather be safe.”
- Another parent shared, “We tried a mattress topper, but it wasn’t firm enough, so we moved back to the bassinet for now.”
These experiences highlight the importance of balancing comfort with safety and doing thorough research before purchasing.
11 Frequently Asked Questions About Pack and Play Mattresses
- Is it safe to add a mattress to a Pack and Play?
- Yes, if the mattress is specifically designed for Pack and Plays, fits snugly with no gaps, and meets safety standards (e.g., Greenguard Gold, CertiPUR-US). Always follow the playard’s manual and safe sleep guidelines.
- Why are Pack and Play mattresses so thin?
- Thin mattresses (1-1.5 inches) are designed to maintain a firm, flat sleep surface to reduce SIDS risk and ensure the playard’s structural stability. Thicker mattresses can create hazards like entrapment or climbing.
- Can I use a standard crib mattress in a Pack and Play?
- No, standard crib mattresses are too thick and large, creating gaps and instability. Use only mattresses designed for Pack and Plays.
- What’s the best thickness for a Pack and Play mattress?
- For infants under 12 months, 1.5 inches or thinner is recommended. For toddlers over 12 months, slightly thicker mattresses (up to 3 inches) may be safe, but check your playard’s guidelines.
- How do I clean a Pack and Play mattress?
- Most mattresses have removable, machine-washable covers. For non-washable covers, spot-clean with mild soap and water. Always air-dry to prevent mold.
- Are organic Pack and Play mattresses worth it?
- Organic mattresses, like the Organic Dream, are ideal for parents seeking chemical-free, hypoallergenic options. They’re pricier but offer peace of mind for sensitive babies.
- Can a Pack and Play mattress be used for overnight sleep?
- Yes, if it meets safety standards and fits properly. However, Pack and Plays are primarily designed for short-term sleep or travel, not as a permanent crib replacement.
- Do Pack and Play mattresses come with sheets?
- Some do, but many require separate sheets. Use sheets made by the playard manufacturer or designed for Pack and Play mattresses to ensure a snug fit.
- How long can my baby use a Pack and Play mattress?
- Most Pack and Plays are safe until your child reaches 30 pounds, 35 inches, or starts climbing out (whichever comes first). Check your playard’s manual for specific limits.
- Are tri-fold mattresses better for travel?
- Yes, tri-fold mattresses (like the Dream On Me or Hiccapop) are lightweight, compact, and often include carrying bags, making them ideal for travel.
- What if my baby doesn’t sleep well in the Pack and Play?
- Try a fitted sheet or a certified mattress for added comfort. Ensure the playard is in a quiet, familiar environment, and maintain consistent bedtime routines. If issues persist, consider a mini-crib for better sleep.
Conclusion: Finding the Perfect Pack and Play Mattress
Choosing the best Pack and Play mattress for your baby involves balancing comfort, safety, and practicality. Our top pick, the Hiccapop Pack and Play Mattress Pad, excels in versatility with its dual-sided design, safety certifications, and portable tri-fold feature. For budget-conscious parents, the Milliard Tri-Fold Mattress offers great value, while the Organic Dream Mattress is perfect for those prioritizing eco-friendly materials. The Dream On Me On-The-Go Mattress shines for frequent travelers, and the Sleepah Mattress is built to last.
Before purchasing, measure your Pack and Play, check safety certifications, and read parent reviews to ensure the mattress meets your needs. Always prioritize safe sleep practices, such as placing your baby on their back and avoiding extra padding. With the right mattress, your baby can enjoy restful naps and playtime wherever life takes you.
Have you used a Pack and Play mattress? Share your experience in the comments below, or let us know which option you’re considering! For more baby gear tips, check out our guides on the best travel cribs and strollers.
